I really like the movie Shortbus (though I like Hedwig a helluva lot better), but there’s one line in there that really pisses me off:
“Let’s face it, monogamy’s for straight people.”
If you haven’t seen Shortbus, it’s a great story about how people connect blah blah blah whatever, and one of the stories within the movie is the relationship between the two Jamies, Jamie Shorthair and Jamie Masturbateatthestartofthemovieandcumsinhisownmouth. They’re complex characters. So, the two are sitting with a Canadian sex therapist and they discuss bringing in a third guy into bed (who turns out to be emo/country YouTube sensation Jay Brannan). Oh, by the way, SPOILERS. Sorry, maybe I should have warned you about that earlier.
Let me start a new paragraph; this is already getting too complex. They talk to the therapist and Jamie Shorthair says that line that pisses me off. Is it really possible that gay men simply have too much testosterone to make a lasting relationship work without bringing in a third guy? One of the “excuses” I have heard from gay guys is that men who date men are more interested in sex than an actual relationship. Is this true?
First, I feel the need to say that no, I do not believe in the nuclear family as being the ideal family. No, a relationship between three partners is not a bad thing. I also don’t necessarily believe that the only good relationship is one that lasts a lifetime. Divorce exists for a reason, and I think that’s a good thing. Personally I want “a” partner, not several, and I do aim to have a life-long relationship. Maybe things won’t work out that way, but this particular blog is going to cater to this way of thinking. Deal with the heteronormativity for just a bit, ok? Cool.
My first explanation for this way of thinking is that laws regarding gay relationships do not promote the same idea that is promoted to heterosexuals. That is, marriage laws for heterosexuals sort of mark a goal for straight relationships: marriage is what you want/need in order to be happy. Gays do not have this privilege, so it is as if there is no aim or goal (if you are willing to label marriage as such). No, marriage is not for everyone, but god leave me alone about being PC and being fair to everyone for a little bit. kthxbye.
Without being granted marriage/unions/whatever gays are not presented such images in the media. The only time I have ever seen a gay couple that lives together was on an episode of Desperate Housewives, and I’m pretty sure they’re evil bastards so who’s to say if that’s necessarily helpful? What we do see is single Will and single Jack on Will & Grace going on continuous dates and never finding love (unless they did, I sort of stopped paying attention, anyone know?). What else do we have? Queer as Folk, aka soft porn and gays getting beaten by baseball bats. Queer Eye: a show which has nothing to do with gays in relationships, but rather promotes somewhat positive stereotypes about gays. And gay movies? Shortbus is great for promoting tolerance of all sexual ways of life, but it doesn’t really show a gay relationship like the one I am looking for. Rocky Horror? No. Bent: great movie about love between gays in a concentration camp, but it kind of ends SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER on a not so happy note.
Going into a gay club presents interesting images as well and I would be willing to say it’s different from a straight club in that the gay clubs are frequented by people of all ages, not just the youth. Why are 50 and 60 year old guys in the scene? By them being there, it’s like they’re saying, “This is how you will live for the rest of your life.” That scares me, because while C St. is fine for dancing and releasing stress now, I don’t want to be going there when I start having hip problems. I’m not always going to be able to shake that groove thang.
I think it’s very possible to have a gay relationship that lasts. Oddly, two of the three examples I have witnessed among my friends are like the Jamies in that both partners share the same name. Kind of freaks me out but I’m down with it. These couples have already lasted many years and I can foresee them doing the whole being in love forever thing. What makes them different from all of my friends who go through relationships every few months? Do they live in Europe and not have to deal with American laws? No. Do they only watch Desperate Housewives? God I hope not. Are they in the scene often? No. Hm. Interesting. Unless there’s something else going on that I’m missing, I think we may have found the problem…








