Matt was actually the first guy I interviewed for the Catholic School Boys, but I saved him for last because I see him as having one of the more conservative backgrounds. If you haven’t realized this by now, one of my main goals with With Tongue is to prove that gay guys can come from many various backgrounds (whether they’re frat boys or Catholics or sissies or jocks). And, when you look into these separate categories, the backgrounds and experiences are often quite varied. No two gay men are the same. Like gay snowflakes.
The next series I will be doing will focus on gays (and, if I can find some, lesbians) who have a disability. I will be conducting interviews within a few weeks, and if you or someone you know would be willing to spend 30-60 minutes talking with me, it would be much appreciated. I can be contacted at withtongue@gmail.com.
And without any further adieu: the conclusion to Catholic School Boys. Matt is a 22 year old grad student at UIUC and went to a non-denominational Christian school in northern Illinois.
W.T. First, sexually how would you define yourself?
Matt: I don’t like to define myself, but I would normally define myself more gay.
W.T. How long did you go to your school?
Matt: From 3rd grade to senior year of high school. It was a whole class of 9 people.
W.T. Wow. What was sex education like at your school?
Matt: There was sex-ed in junior high. It was abstinence only. Sex was against the rules of the school, not to mention gay sex.
W.T. So it was abstinence only. When did you find out about contraception?
Matt: Oh, I don’t know. It was probably through parents, friends, and TV. Even though it was a Christian school it definitely wasn’t purist. I think I found out about sex from a friend in the third grade. But sex ed was definitely abstinence only and that was also pushed in Bible classes and what not. We had to take those every year.
W.T. Did they teach you about the reproductive system?
Matt: Yeah, sure, in biology. We learned where babies come from and everything. A lot of what they taught us about sex was a moral thing, not so much a focus on babies and STDs and AIDS. We had this class, Contemporary World Views, where they teach you about all these world views like Marxism, communism. And in the actual curriculum homosexuality was thrown in there.
W.T. Like right next to Nazis?
Matt: Haha, yeah, but the year I took it they took the homosexuality section out. The year before there were videos with the class and one of the videos showed two guys kidding. Some of the parents got upset and made them take it out.
W.T. When they talked about these views did they label any of them as bad?
Matt: No, overall that course was done well, but mostly because of the teacher that taught it. They would also say this is what they believe and contrast it with what Christian believe, but they wouldn’t say it’s necessarily bad.
W.T. That’s cool, so would you say your school was actually more liberal?
Matt: No. Not at all. We have two principals, and one of them is the kind of guy who thinks of tie-dye as the devil. Conservative. If he knew I was gay, he probably wouldn’t let me back in the school when I go home.
W.T. Alright, and do your parents know?
Matt: Yes. They kind of forced it out of me my sophomore year of college. I actually didn’t come out to anyone, or even myself until freshman year of college. The school was very conservative in that sense.
W.T. When do you think you first realized you were gay then?
Matt: Oh, in like junior high when I messed around with guys.
W.T. So tell me why you didn’t come out until college then.
Matt: Mostly because of the conservative viewpoint and I think a lot of my friends would not be okay with it. A lot of my high school friends don’t know. Or maybe they do now, I haven’t talked to a lot of them in a while. It was sort of like peer pressure I guess but really it was just the idea of “you don’t do that.” Even though junior year of high school I kind of had a thing with a school administrator’s son. And today he’s completely in the closet and getting married to a girl. But that’s a different story.
W.T. That sounds like a good story.
Matt: Let’s put it this way, all the guys I’ve ever dated are “straight.”
W.T. That sounds like really bad luck. Are you seeing anyone now?
Matt: No, not seeing anyone right now. Well, so then there’s the interesting thing in college, where I dated a girl. And this was after I came out. But we kind of just hit it off. And so then we decided to stop dating because I wasn’t really sure … well this is why I say I don’t define myself. I guess you could say I’m gay except for her. We’re totally still best friends and kind of sort of dating again, but not really. It’s interesting.
W.T. Are you still religious now? Were you even religious then?
Matt: Yes and no and yes. I definitely grew up in the church and my whole family is all about religion. It’s important. I was religious then. I did everything. I went to youth group and to church and did everything I was supposed to. I was a good little boy. Then in college I found a church that isn’t okay with gays, but they’re open about it. They’ll talk about it. It wasn’t like my church or school back home where the only mention of it was that you’re going to Hell.
W.T. What does this church say about it?
Matt: They think it’s sin, but they’re of the mindset of hate the sin, love the sinner. I started going to that and I’ve gone to it for a while. I did that for a church thing, but I also tried the no religion at all thing. Now I am back with the doing religion, but not organized religion. It’s been a lot of back and forth. My mom doesn’t accept that I like guys and that guys are hot, but she’s … she asked me a couple weeks ago if I was going to date my ex-girlfriend again. She’s a little bit about it right now but she’s still holding out. Thinking of it as a phase. A long phase. And she’s the fun mom who when she found out she asked me if I really wanted to have anal sex.
W.T. Haha, how did you answer?!
Matt: I stood up and laughed and walked away.
W.T. I hope you were walking crooked or something. So you say you’re religious but not necessarily organized. Do you follow a Bible at all?
Matt: Yeah, it’s a bit hard to explain. I would say I follow the basic beliefs of Evangelical Christianity but I haven’t completely settled on what I believe on the no gays or not verses.
W.T. What do you think about those verses?
Matt: I don’t like to think about them. Haha, they tell me I can’t do what I want to do! I have a wide range of friends and I have some who went to the church I am usually associated with. And they left that church because they decided they wanted to pursue gay relationships. That’s the thing, it’s cool if you’re in the church, but not if you’re acting on it. Two of them left, got married, and they go to the Quaker church. The Quaker church is okay with it. They got married in the Quaker church. They got married in Illinois last summer and they got legally married in Iowa.
W.T. How do you feel about gay marriage?
Matt: Well, I’m the bad gay guy who doesn’t care if it’s called marriage. I would be cool if it’s civil unions as long as it’s the exact same thing. A big part of the debate is just the word and I don’t find it necessary.
W.T. So you would say that marriage is between a man and a woman in the church?
Matt: I would say that’s how the church defines it. Personally I don’t care. And I would be perfectly fine with it not being called marriage for gays.
W.T. Do you ever foresee yourself getting married to a man? Or “civil unioned?”
Matt: Well, I foresee myself getting married in the future. There’s still the girlfriend thing.
W.T. Back to high school, what was dating like?
Matt: It was a little strange because it was such a small school. All my friends shared girlfriends, you know? Cause they’d break up or whatever. And that’d be strange because she’d put out for one guy and not the other. You always knew when people were sleeping together. They were sleeping together on teachers’ desks.
W.T. What! How is that possible? Where do you find the time?
Matt: Drama club, after school.
W.T. Oh, of course.
Matt: While we were taught abstinence, it definitely did not happen. When I was in 8th grade or a freshman, there were some guys in the high school who came out to some people. They ended up leaving the school. They left before they were asked to. That’s against the rules. It’s not morally acceptable. They would have been asked to leave because they were bad influences. Private schools don’t have any regulations so they can do that. The same thing would happen with people doing drugs.
W.T. Ah, so homosexuality, heroin…
Matt: Pot, yeah, it’s all the same thing.
W.T. The school considers it sexual deviance. What do you consider sexual deviance?
Matt: I think before I would have said … well I was the type of person who was not going to have sex before marriage, but maybe I would do other things.
W.T. Is that still true for you?
Matt: Yes. I haven’t had sex before marriage. I don’t know how strongly I still feel about that though. I think it’s more of a committed thing, not a marriage thing. Maybe partially do to the fact that you can’t legally get married in the state.
W.T. Unless you’re with the Quakers. But I guess that isn’t necessarily coming with legal rights. How do you feel about the priest scandal? How did it affect your view on homosexuality?
Matt: I don’t think it changed my view a lot actually. My view on homosexuality in the church is that they don’t do it right. I’m okay with churches saying that they don’t think it’s right, but I don’t agree with how they act towards it. That they make it one of those unmentionable topics and that it’s among the worst sins. The church’s view and treatment of it needs to be different. It needs to be more of an open discussion.
W.T. How do you feel about the organizations that try to convert you from homosexual to heterosexual?
Matt: Like Exodus? That’s the big one. I don’t want to speak too harshly. I don’t like them. I have a lot of friends that have done it. I have a few friends who have done it and say they’re straight. But it’s not that simple. One of the guys would say he’s straight, but he’ll also have days where he will feel gay. He’s really attracted to guys. But he feels that the Bible is right and that it’s wrong, and therefore he’s going to compromise his sexuality for religion. It’s something I’m not willing to do. At least I don’t think I am. I’d have a really hard time doing it, I think. Choosing one or the other is giving up on something that’s a part of me.
W.T. Can you tell me a little bit more about your friend who’s straight now?
Matt: He at least at one point had a girlfriend. I know he doesn’t have one now. He think it’s not right to be gay so he’s not gonna do it. I’m sure he’s sexually frustrated. He definitely deals with it on a daily basis. He actually works for a church and he’s in seminary right now. He’s definitely committed to it. He has an interesting story too and I won’t really get into it, but he was totally a little slut before that.
END PART 1
Coming up in Part 2: guilt, spirituality, dating, whether or not it’s a choice, and more on the administrator’s son