The editors at Smile Politely have come out with a list of the top ten CU-connected books of the decade, a mighty list to be sure. And a mighty task.
I respect this list for the most part, and it should come as no surprise that notable appearances are made by nationally prominent residents, former community members and University of Illinois faculty members such as Richard Powers, Roger Ebert, David Foster Wallace, Janice Harrington and Brigit Pegeen Kelly. This really is a superb roster that makes you feel proud of the concentration of intellectual and literary ability in these cities, but there just seemed to be a glaring omission in the exclusion of one now-prominent literary rock star/icon–Pulitzer Prize finalist and former Illinois student Dave Eggers.
Perhaps known best for his 2000 memoir A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius Eggers is a stylistic innovator frequently ranked, for his contributions to indie publishing and community/social involvement, in lists like Time Magazine’s Hundred Most Influential People or Rolling Stone’s 100 Agents of Change.
Is this exclusion purely one of literary taste or a failure to own the student population as part of the Champaign-Urbana community? Does is rest on the assumption that Eggers only saw himself as a transient denizen? I’m almost inclined toward believing, mind you on no empirical grounds, that this list is a combination of all of those things with a wee bit of refusal to bolster the status of an icon with a probably already bloated ego.
As an Illinois student with limited mobility and excessive time commitments, it’s sometimes hard to believe that there is a life outside of Campustown though my bed is, I’m told, in downtown Urbana. The student population is predominantly busy, motionless, transplanted, and engrossed in a campus culture alien to the community at large. The only strange thing with this list is that it does not reflect that in its selection criteria–David Foster Wallace grew up here as the son of a professor and took off. Roger Ebert grew up, went to school, and then hit the bricks. Other writers on the list are faculty at the University who moved here later in life. It seems that the community-at-large has every respect for the people who go forth from here as well as the people who wind up here at 45, but not as much for those whose stated purpose is to come as adults with the widely received expectation that they will go away again in four years.
CU is dependent on this University, and the University would not be the place that it is without the beautiful community here, but somehow, we, as a student population, continue in a pervasive apathy for the local businesses, people, and scenes which surround us, and we’re all worse off for that lack of exchange. But, say you don’t want the Big Ten student culture to infiltrate the downtown city bars, theatres and music venues due to fear of some sort of vague notion like gentrifcation. Then is Campustown not its own urban neighborhood, as much a part of CU as the strip malls and subdivisions on the outskirts or the downtown main streets and commercial buildings?
Still, is it cool with you if I start to ditch Murphy’s for the Iron Post? I mean, I do like live music more than juke boxes. Since I’ve spent some of the most formative years of my life on the U of I campus and, to a lesser extent at Merry-Anne’s, the Boardman Art Theatre and the Rose Bowl, can I tell the rest of the world that I came from Chicago by way of Urbana?
Matt
PS–For shits and giggles, I came across this interesting 2003 interview of David Foster Wallace by Dave Eggers in The Believer while I was pretending to do some research for this post. This is all the sexy, digressive, cutting-edge, post-modern Urbana-related thought that one web page can handle. Enjoy.